Comparison

Is FX Replay free? What it does, and what Tradoshi adds

Let us say it before anything else: FX Replay is a backtesting platform first, Tradoshi a trading journal first. Their own site describes it as “a browser-based backtesting and trading practice platform”. The two products overlap on two points, and they need naming: FX Replay has added a journal that already syncs cTrader and TradeLocker accounts, Tradoshi has added a replay backtest on its Pro and Premium plans. On replay, they go further than we do. Sourced on 10 September 2026 from their public pages.

Sourced on 10 September 2026

Tradoshi is forunderstanding what you do when the money is real: your broker syncs, your trades are measured, your state is captured before the session, and your rules are checked against your actions. Backtesting is only one module here, from the Pro plan.

FX Replay is forpractising on past markets: replaying candles down to the second, testing a strategy on more than twenty years of forex history, simulating a prop firm challenge without risking anything. On that ground it is more complete and cheaper than we are.

The right answeroften both. They cross over on the journal and on backtesting, but each is the better of the two on its own ground, and a trader who has opened both sees it straight away.

Tradoshi and FX Replay at a glance

13 lines to decide fast, then the detail below with the sources read on FX Replay.

What is compared	FX Replay	Tradoshi
Product type	Backtesting platform, with a journal	Trading journal, with a backtest
Replay precision	Tick data, down to the second on Pro	Candle by candle, minute data
Backtesting on the free plan	Yes, 2 sessions	No, from Pro
Prop firm challenge simulator	Yes, on historical data	No
Paid entry price	$17.99/mo	$19.99/mo
Free plan	Yes, no card, no end date	Yes, forever, no card, no trade limit
Real account sync	cTrader and TradeLocker, the rest by file import	MetaTrader 4 and 5, cTrader, TradeLocker, IBKR, NinjaTrader, IG
AI coach on real trades	Mentor AI mainly on backtests, AI tag analysis in the journal	Yes, Oshi, from Essential
Tracking a real prop firm challenge	Not described on their pages, only the simulator is	Yes, from Pro
Pre-trade psychology	Absent from their pages	Voice check-in, from Essential
Discipline score	Absent from their pages	From the free plan
Human mentor	Absent from their pages, their “Mentor” is an AI	Free mentor account
Mobile app	None announced, browser-based product	Android published on Google Play, iOS not published to date

1. What FX Replay and Tradoshi each offer, plan by plan

Every FX Replay plan and every one of ours, with what each actually unlocks. Prices are those shown on both pricing pages on 10 September 2026.

FX Replay

Billed in dollars, monthly or yearly

Beginner

free, no card, no end date

2 backtest sessions
50 trades per session, sessions of one month at most
1 indicator
Data kept 1 week
Journal included, 1 screenshot and 1 checklist
No AI queries announced

Intermediate

$17.99/mo

or $180/year ($15/mo)

10 sessions, 200 trades per session
3 indicators, 2 charts
3 strategies, Monte Carlo and R:R simulator
Data kept 6 months
Prop firm challenge simulator
Limited AI queries

Pro

$35/mo

or $350/year ($29.16/mo)

Everything unlimited: sessions, trades, strategies
Second-level data and custom timeframes
Futures and CME data
Data kept with no limit
Unlimited charts and indicators
Unlimited AI queries

Tradoshi

Billed in dollars

NewFree

$0/mo

permanent, no card, nothing to cancel

1 synced broker account
Unlimited file import and manual entry
Full journal, dashboard and Day View
500+ reports and Oshi Score
Discipline score
Free mentor account

Essential

$19.99/mo

or $199/year ($16.58/mo)

Broker sync, 3 accounts
Oshi AI coach on your data
600 AI credits per month
Voice check-in and written
Risk management and economic calendar
No trade limit

Most popularPro

$39.99/mo

or $399/year ($33.25/mo)

50 accounts, multi prop firm
Prop firm challenge tracking
1,500 AI credits
Backtesting (10 strategies)
Be followed by a mentor, free for them
Risk tracking and economic calendar

Premium

$49.99/mo

or $499/year ($41.58/mo)

Unlimited accounts
3,000 AI credits
Live session: in-session guardrails
Trade Review on the real chart
Unlimited backtesting
Priority support

Every price on this page is in dollars, on both sides, and no exchange rate is applied. FX Replay prices were read from their pricing page on 10 September 2026. It shows $15 and $29.16 a month by default: those are their annual prices spread over twelve months, the monthly prices being $17.99 and $35. Their paid plans can be tried for free with no card, but the trial length is not published. They also accept payment in cryptocurrency.

On price, FX Replay wins at every tier, and there is no arguing it. What changes is what you buy: there, $35 pays for a complete replay platform; here, $39.99 pays for a synced journal where backtesting is one module. If your need is to replay the market, they are cheaper and more complete. If it is to measure your real trades and your discipline, their grid has nothing equivalent to our check-ins, our discipline score or real challenge tracking.

2. The partner offer, in months of revenue

FX Replay publishes its schedule, and it is readable: “Earn 20% in recurring commissions for life when you refer users”. Their Partners program goes up to 25% recurring, provided you bring twenty new sales within three consecutive months. The cookie lasts 60 days and the referred user gets a 15% discount.

This time, the rival schedule beats ours at entry: 20% for life from the first sale, against 15% with us. We move to 20% from fifteen active subscribers and to 25% from fifty-one. Their upper tier is earned on a sales pace, ours on a number of active subscribers.

Comparing two percentages means nothing while the durations differ. The honest unit is months of the referred customer's revenue: it neutralises both the product price and the commission duration. Read it as: for a customer who stays N months, the partner has earned the equivalent of X months of that customer's revenue.

Program	Stays 6 months	Stays 12 months	Stays 24 months	Stays 36 months
FX Replay 20% (from the 1st sale)	1.20	2.40	4.80	7.20
Tradoshi 15% (from the 1st customer)	0.90	1.80	3.60	5.40
Tradoshi 20% (15 customers and up)	1.20	2.40	4.80	7.20
Tradoshi 25% (51 customers and up)	1.50	3.00	6.00	9.00

The table says it plainly: at 20% against 15%, FX Replay pays out a third more of each customer's revenue, and the gap never closes over time since both programs pay for life. Our slightly higher prices narrow it without erasing it: 20% of $17.99 is $3.60 a month, 15% of $19.99 is $3.00. Their Partners tier is not computed here, because their page calls it recurring without writing its duration.

What remains on our side, and it is thin. Our 25% tier is kept on a stock of active subscribers, where theirs requires twenty new sales in three months, and their page does not say whether that pace must be kept afterwards. On the other hand their payout threshold is much lower: $50 according to the program details, $100 according to their FAQ, against €500 with us.

On our side, the commission lands on every payment collected, with a 30-day holding period and a €500 payout threshold. For a creator, the two recommendations do not really compete: a trader who backtests on FX Replay is still a prospect for a journal of their real trades.

3. Mentoring, and who pays for whom

The word “mentor” does appear on FX Replay's site, but it refers to an artificial intelligence: Mentor AI, which comments on your backtest sessions. Neither their pricing grid nor the feature pages read on 10 September 2026 describe inviting a human mentor, or sharing an account with an educator or students.

At Tradoshi, the mentor account is free, and the mentor is a person. The student is the subscriber, from the Pro plan up, and invites their mentor, who pays nothing to follow their trades and progress.

For a trader practising alone this line does not count, and their AI may be enough. For a school or an educator it changes everything: students can backtest on FX Replay and be followed on their real trades in Tradoshi, without the educator paying a subscription for themselves.

How mentoring works at Tradoshi · The offer for educators and schools

4. The full comparison, feature by feature

Every line comes from both public pricing pages, read on the same day. Nothing is pulled from a help centre on one side and a grid on the other: on unequal evidence, a comparison stops being honest. “Absent from the grid” means exactly that, not “does not exist”.

Replay and backtesting

Their trade, and they are ahead. Our backtest is a module of the journal, built to validate a strategy before trading it, not a complete simulation platform.

What is compared	FX Replay	Tradoshi
Replay data	Tick, second-level timeframes on Pro	Minute-level, aggregated to your timeframe
Backtesting on the free plan	Yes, 2 sessions of 50 trades	No
Backtest strategies	3 on Intermediate, unlimited on Pro at $35	10 on Pro, unlimited on Premium at $49.99
Prop firm challenge simulator	Yes, rules enforced on historical data, from Intermediate	No
Simulated execution costs	Configurable spreads and commissions	Spread, slippage, commission and swap
Automatic break-even	Yes, from Intermediate	Yes, with partial exits

The journal of real trades

The ground where the two meet. FX Replay already syncs cTrader and TradeLocker accounts, and that must be said. The difference lies in how many platforms are connected, and in what the journal then does with your trades.

What is compared	FX Replay	Tradoshi
Journal included on the free plan	Yes, on every plan	Yes, with 1 synced broker
Synced platforms	cTrader and TradeLocker. MT4, MT5, NinjaTrader and Tradovate announced as “coming soon”	MetaTrader 4 and 5, cTrader, TradeLocker, IBKR, NinjaTrader, IG
File import	CSV from any platform, including MT4, MT5, NinjaTrader and Tradovate	Unlimited, from the free plan
AI analysis	Tag engine, and Mentor AI mainly on backtests	Oshi Coach on your real trades, from Essential
Prop firm tracking	Simulation only, according to their pages	Real challenge and multi prop firm (Pro)

Discipline and psychology

None of this appears on their pages as of 10 September 2026. Their answer to psychology is to practise with no money at stake, ours is to measure what happens when there is some.

What is compared	FX Replay	Tradoshi
Emotional check-in	Absent from their pages	Written, and voice from Essential
Discipline score	Absent from their pages	From the free plan
In-session guardrails	Absent from their pages	Live session (Premium)
Human mentor account	Absent from their pages, their “Mentor” is an AI	Free for the mentor

Access and billing

They are cheaper at every paid tier, and we do not dispute it. Our only row here is mobile.

What is compared	FX Replay	Tradoshi
Paid entry price	$17.99/mo	$19.99/mo
Most complete plan	$35/mo	$49.99/mo
Annual pricing	$180 or $350 a year	$199, $399 or $499 a year
Mobile app	None announced, browser-based product	Android published on Google Play, iOS not published to date

Look up your broker in our list · See all three plans in detail · Watch the video demo

5. What we concede to FX Replay

A comparison won on every single line is not a comparison, it is an advert. Here are the points where FX Replay is ahead, with nothing taken off.

Their replay goes deeper than oursTick data, second-level timeframes on the Pro plan, history going back to 2003 on the major forex pairs, futures, stocks, indices and crypto markets, multi-chart and indicators on TradingView charts. Our backtest replays the market honestly, hidden future and real costs included, but on minute data, and it is a journal module, not a simulation platform.

Their backtesting starts free, ours at $39.99Their free plan gives two sessions of fifty trades, and their Intermediate at $17.99 gives ten, with three strategies. Our backtesting only exists from the Pro plan. For someone who only wants to replay the market, the price gap is clear.

The prop firm challenge simulator exists only thereYou set the profit target, maximum drawdown, daily loss and minimum number of days, and their rules apply on their own while you trade the history, with unlimited attempts. We track real challenges, we do not simulate them.

They are cheaper at every paid tier$17.99 against $19.99 at entry, $35 against $49.99 at the top, $180 and $350 a year against $199 to $499. Even accounting for what each plan contains, the gap is real.

Their affiliate program pays more at entry20% for life from the first sale against 15% with us, a payout threshold of $50 according to their program details ($100 according to their FAQ) against €500, and a 15% discount for the referred user. For a creator starting out, their schedule is better.

Their interface speaks eight languagesEnglish, Spanish, German, French, Turkish, Ukrainian, Portuguese and Russian, according to their help centre. We offer fewer.

The verdict

If you are looking for a replay tool, FX Replay is more complete and cheaper than our backtest, and we would rather tell you so. Tick data, twenty years of history, futures and stocks, a challenge simulator: our module does not have that depth. FX Replay answers “would my strategy have worked?” Tradoshi answers “am I really applying it, with real money?”: losing streaks, hours, emotional state, discipline, a real prop firm challenge. The backtest proves an edge exists, the journal proves you trade it. The setup that makes the most sense: backtest on FX Replay, trade and measure on Tradoshi.

Frequently asked questions

Is FX Replay free?

Yes, it has a free plan, Beginner, with no card and no end date. It gives two backtest sessions of fifty trades each, with one indicator, and it includes their journal. Tradoshi also has a free-forever plan with no card, but it journals: our backtesting starts on the Pro plan.

How much does FX Replay cost?

Sourced on 10 September 2026 from their pricing page: $17.99 per month for Intermediate and $35 for Pro, or $180 and $350 a year, which comes to $15 and $29.16 a month. That is cheaper than our paid plans at every tier, which are $19.99, $39.99 and $49.99 per month.

Does FX Replay offer a free trial?

Their pricing page announces a free trial on the paid plans, with no card, but does not publish its length. At Tradoshi, the free plan has no end date, so there is nothing to cancel.

Is FX Replay a trading journal?

Partly. It is a backtesting platform first, but its journal, included on all their plans, already syncs cTrader and TradeLocker accounts in real time. MetaTrader 4 and 5, NinjaTrader and Tradovate come in today by file import, their sync being announced as “coming soon”, and the CSV import accepts any platform. What you will not find there is the discipline layer: no emotional check-in, no discipline score, no tracking of a real prop firm challenge.

Is Tradoshi an FX Replay alternative?

Not for replay, and it is better to say so. Our backtest replays the market candle by candle, future hidden, with real execution costs, but it works on minute data and remains a module of the Pro plan. If replay is your main need, FX Replay is more complete. Tradoshi is an alternative to their journal, not to their simulator.

What does FX Replay do better than Tradoshi?

Five things. A deeper replay, tick-level and down to the second. Backtesting from the free plan. A prop firm challenge simulator on historical data. Lower prices at every paid tier. An interface in eight languages.

What does Tradoshi do that FX Replay does not?

Five things absent from their pages as of 10 September 2026: the written and voice emotional check-in before the session, the discipline score, tracking of a real prop firm challenge, in-session guardrails, and the free mentor account for a human educator. Add to that syncing MetaTrader, IBKR, NinjaTrader and IG: on their side, only cTrader and TradeLocker sync today.

Try it, and compare on your own trades

Connect your broker, let your journal fill itself, and judge on your own numbers rather than on a table.

Start for free Free plan · no credit card · nothing to cancel

Method and sources. Every figure attributed to FX Replay was read on 10 September 2026 on its own public pages, in the served HTML, and not taken from a third-party comparison: fxreplay.com/ · fxreplay.com/pricing · fxreplay.com/backtest · fxreplay.com/trading-journal · fxreplay.com/prop-firm-simulator · fxreplay.com/ai-trading-mentor · fxreplay.com/affiliate · support.fxreplay.com/. The “absent from the grid” statements were obtained by counting term occurrences in the served page, not by eye. The months-of-revenue values are computed from the published schedules on both sides, month by month, not typed by hand. A publisher's pricing can change without notice, sometimes overnight: when in doubt, the FX Replay page prevails over this one. If you spot a mistake, write to us and it will be corrected with the date. Report an error to us.