Comparison
Tradoshi vs Plancana
Plancana is the closest competitor to us on substance: its tagline is “AI-powered trading journal for emotional discipline”, which is exactly our promise. It is also a mobile app, billed through the app stores, by the week. That last point deserves some arithmetic, and that is what this page is about.
Sourced on 2 August 2026
The comparison at a glance
Thirteen lines to decide fast. Everything is detailed below, with sources.
| What is compared | Plancana | Tradoshi |
|---|---|---|
| Emotional discipline | Yes, it is their tagline | Yes, it is our promise |
| Free plan | Yes, forever, no card | No, 7-day trial |
| Advertised price | $2.99 and $8.99 per week | $19.99 to $49.99 per month |
| Real cost over a year | $155 and $467 | $199 to $499 |
| Broker sync | Only on the $467/year plan | From the entry plan, $199/year |
| Brokers and platforms | 4: MT4, MT5, ByBit, TradeLocker | 2,000+, list and PDF published |
| Voice check-in | Absent from their grid | From Pro |
| Human mentoring | “Trading Mentor” = their AI, not a person | Free mentor account |
| Mobile app | iOS and Android, published | iOS and Android, being published |
| Web app | Absent from their site | Yes, the main product |
| Backtesting and replay | Absent from their grid | Backtesting and Trade Review |
| Prop firm and challenge tracking | Absent from their pricing grid | Multi prop firm and challenge |
1. The customer offer, plan by plan
Both publishers' three plans, with what each one actually unlocks. Prices are the ones shown on both pricing pages on the day of the survey.
Plancana
Billed through the App Store and Google Play$0
forever, no credit card- Manually entered journal
- Weekly analytics only
- Trading Plan Generator
- AI mentor free for 3 days
- No broker sync
$2.99/week
that is $155 a year- Weekly, monthly and yearly analytics
- Risk analysis
- Ongoing AI mentor
- Still no sync: “for trades you log”
$8.99/week
that is $467 a year- Everything in Basic, plus:
- MT4, MT5, ByBit, TradeLocker sync
- Real-time trade tracking
- Advanced portfolio analytics
Tradoshi
Billed in dollars$19.99/mo
or $199/year ($16.58/mo)- No trade limit
- 3 connected broker accounts
- 600 AI credits per month
- Oshi AI coach on your data
- Discipline score and written check-in
- 500+ reports and Oshi Score
$29.99/mo
or $299/year ($24.92/mo)- 50 accounts, multi prop firm, challenge tracking
- 1,500 AI credits
- Voice check-in and emotion detection
- Prescriptive AI daily reco
- Backtesting (10 strategies)
- Mentor invited for free
$49.99/mo
or $499/year ($41.58/mo)- Unlimited accounts
- 3,000 AI credits
- Live session: in-session guardrails
- Trade Review on the real chart
- Unlimited backtesting
- Priority support
Every price on this page is in dollars, on both sides, and no exchange rate is applied. Plancana's annual figures are computed from their weekly display, over 52 weeks: 2.99 × 52 = $155.48 and 8.99 × 52 = $467.48. Their page also offers monthly and quarterly displays.
Two things hide behind the weekly display, and neither is a lie on their part: the framing does the work. One: “$8.99 per week” reads like a coffee, “$467 a year” reads like a decision. It is the same money. Two, and this matters more: broker sync is not in their middle plan. Their Basic at $2.99 analyses “trades you log”, so by hand. For the broker to feed the journal on its own, you need their top plan, $467 a year. With us, sync is there from $199 a year.
2. The partner offer, in months of revenue
Plancana shows a “Partner Program” in its footer, but no terms are published: no rate, no duration, no payout threshold. On top of that comes a mobile constraint: their subscriptions go through the App Store and Google Play, which take their own cut before anything is passed on.
Our schedule is public and pays from the first customer: 15% for life on every payment collected, 20% from fifteen active subscribers, 25% from fifty-one.
Comparing two percentages means nothing while the durations differ. The honest unit is months of the referred customer's revenue: it neutralises both the product price and the commission duration. Read it as: for a customer who stays N months, the partner has earned the equivalent of X months of that customer's revenue.
| Program | Stays 6 months | Stays 12 months | Stays 24 months | Stays 36 months |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tradoshi 15% (from the 1st customer) | 0.90 | 1.80 | 3.60 | 5.40 |
| Tradoshi 20% (15 customers and up) | 1.20 | 2.40 | 4.80 | 7.20 |
| Tradoshi 25% (51 customers and up) | 1.50 | 3.00 | 6.00 | 9.00 |
The table only holds our rows, for lack of a published competing schedule. It reads in months of the referred customer's revenue.
On our side, the commission lands on every payment collected, with a 30-day holding period and a €500 payout threshold.
3. Mentoring, and who pays for whom
Careful with the wording, it is confusing. Plancana's “Trading Mentor” is not a person: it is the name of their AI assistant, free for three days then reserved for paid plans. There is nothing on their pricing page allowing an educator to follow a student.
At Tradoshi the mentor is a person, and their account is free. The student is the subscriber from Pro up and invites their mentor, who sees their trades, notes and progress without paying anything.
The two products use the word mentor for two different things, and that is the thing to remember. There, the mentor is an artificial intelligence. Here, the AI is called Oshi and the mentor is your coach. For a school the difference is not semantic, it decides everything: an artificial intelligence does not supervise a cohort.
How mentoring works at Tradoshi · The offer for educators and schools
4. The full comparison, feature by feature
Every line comes from both public pricing pages, read on the same day. Nothing is pulled from a help centre on one side and a grid on the other: on unequal evidence, a comparison stops being honest. “Absent from the grid” means exactly that, not “does not exist”.
Where broker sync sits
This is the line with the heaviest consequences, because a journal filled by hand ends up not being filled. There, sync is reserved for the most expensive plan.
| What is compared | Plancana | Tradoshi |
|---|---|---|
| Sync on the free plan | No | No free plan |
| Sync on the mid plan | No: “for trades you log” | Yes |
| Annual price of the first syncing plan | $467 | $199 |
| Brokers and platforms | 4: MT4, MT5, ByBit, TradeLocker | 2,024 + PDF, 98 on a direct API |
| Prop firm and challenge tracking | Absent from their pricing grid | Multi prop firm and challenge tracking |
Emotional discipline, on both sides
Shared ground, and it should be said plainly: they have been there since 2024 and it is their main promise. The difference is in how the trader's state is captured.
| What is compared | Plancana | Tradoshi |
|---|---|---|
| Emotional discipline promise | Yes, their tagline | Yes, our promise |
| Written check-in | Yes, in the journal | Yes, from the entry plan |
| Voice check-in and emotion detection | Absent from their grid | From Pro |
| Numeric discipline score | Absent from their grid | From the entry plan |
| Generated trading plan | Yes, from the free plan | Prescriptive daily reco (Pro) |
Where you keep your journal
Two products designed for two different places. That is not an ergonomics detail, it changes who uses them.
| What is compared | Plancana | Tradoshi |
|---|---|---|
| Mobile app | iOS and Android, published since 2024 | iOS and Android, being published |
| Web app | Absent from their site | Yes, it is the main product |
| Payment method | App Store and Google Play only | Card, invoice available |
| Backtesting | Absent from their grid | 10 strategies then unlimited |
| Trade replay | Absent from their grid | Trade Review on the real chart |
| Languages | English | French and English |
Look up your broker in our list · See all three plans in detail · Watch the video demo
5. What we concede to Plancana
A comparison won on every single line is not a comparison, it is an advert. Here are the points where Plancana is ahead, with nothing taken off.
The verdict
This is the comparison where both products promise the same thing, so the only place to look is execution. Three questions settle it. Which screen do you journal on? If it is a phone, their app exists and ours does not, question closed. How much are you willing to pay for your broker to feed your journal on its own? There it is $467 a year, here $199, and that is the most concrete gap on this page. Is your mentor a person? Their “Trading Mentor” is an artificial intelligence. If a coach follows you, they can see nothing there, and they see everything here without paying.
Frequently asked questions
What does Plancana really cost per year?
Their prices are displayed per week. Over 52 weeks, the Basic plan at $2.99 comes to $155 a year, and the Pro plan at $8.99 comes to $467 a year. The arithmetic is ours, from their display recorded on 2 August 2026; their page also offers monthly and quarterly displays.
Does Plancana sync my broker?
Only on its most expensive plan. Their page states that the Basic plan gives analytics “for trades you log”, so by hand. MetaTrader 4 and 5, ByBit and TradeLocker sync is reserved for the Pro plan at $8.99 per week, which is $467 a year. At Tradoshi sync is included from the entry plan, at $199 a year.
Is Plancana's “Trading Mentor” a real mentor?
No, it is the name of their AI assistant, free for three days then included in paid plans. Nothing on their pricing page lets a human coach follow a student. At Tradoshi the AI is called Oshi and the mentor is a person, whose account is free.
How many brokers does each support?
Plancana announces four: MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, ByBit and TradeLocker. Tradoshi announces more than 2,000 brokers and publishes the list of 2,024, name by name, with a proof PDF and each connection mode, 98 of them on a direct broker API.
What does Plancana do better than Tradoshi?
Five things. A permanent free plan with no card. A mobile app published on both stores since 2024, while ours is being published. A trading plan generator free from the free plan. In-app billing, with no card form. And a two-year head start on the emotional discipline positioning.
Compare with another trading journal
Try it, and compare on your own trades
Connect your broker, let your journal fill itself, and judge on your own numbers rather than on a table.
Start for free 7-day trial · then from $19.99/month · cancel in one clickMethod and sources. Every figure attributed to Plancana was read on 2 August 2026 on its own public pages, in the served HTML, and not taken from a third-party comparison: plancana.com/pricing. The “absent from the grid” statements were obtained by counting term occurrences in the served page, not by eye. The months-of-revenue values are computed from the published schedules on both sides, month by month, not typed by hand. A publisher's pricing changes without notice, and this one raised all three of its plans overnight on 16 July 2026: when in doubt, the publisher's own page prevails over this one. If you spot a mistake, write to us and it will be corrected with the date. Report an error to us.